Customer Success | 4 MIN READ

Top 8 Customer Success Manager Mistakes

We have put together a list of Top 8 Customer Success Manager Mistakes which customer success leaders and their teams make.

Anshi Bhadoria
May 13, 2020


We have put together a list of top 8 customer success manager mistakes which customer success leaders and their teams make.

top 8 customer success manager mistakes

#1 Not Putting the Customer First

customer success mistake

Referred to as the ‘golden rule of customer success,’ the entire idea of putting the customer first is the epitome of GREAT customer success. Often, Customer Success Managers (CSMs), leaders, or even company executives try to push the customers into doing what they are not ready for yet like agreeing to an upsell or activating a new department. Step back and make sure that decisions are taken with the customer’s best interests in mind.

#2 Not Segmenting Customers

CSM mistake

Services provided to your largest customers might be overkill for your smaller ones. And if you limit the benefits for your larger clients to the extent that you offer your smaller ones, you risk not meeting their needs. Creating customer segments and letting that guide the time allocation and touchpoints would be appreciated both by your organization as well as your customers.

#3 Driving Too Many Things at Once

top customer success mistake

Customer Success Managers sometimes try too many things at once, from platform updates to relationship building e-mails, setting up update calls to sharing best practices content, throwing in some professional service offerings, following up on customer education training, and more. Take the time to plan and pace things out; you cannot afford to be the one creating fatigue in the relationship.

#4 Going Crazy with the KPIs

As a Customer Success Manager, you want to achieve all the goals. However, it is impossible to improve everything at once: the onboarding process, retention, MRR growth, and upsell, among other things. If you chase too many rabbits, you will catch none. Make a plan on what needs current attention, share with leadership, and then focus on them until you get positive results. Only once you achieve the initial goals, should you move to the next few.

#5 Not planning Out your Day

As a Customer Success Manager, your days can be very different. If you let your email inbox take you where it will, every morning, you will find yourself spending time handling only the urgent issues, and never be able to make time for the important. Create guidelines that you can use to stay on track throughout the day, and always allocate time for (and block on your calendar), slots that will let you think through and execute improvement.

#6 Confusing Silence with Success

top CSM mistake

Some Customer Success Managers assume that silence from a customer translates to their being happy with the service/product. Diligently monitor metrics and data that bring to light underlying issues or red flags. If that doesn’t throw up anything, try to use your high touch or tech touchpoints to gauge the satisfaction levels. Do what it takes to avoid getting surprised by churn, as much as possible.

#7 Failing to Manage Expectations 

Even if everything else were working well, if a Customer Success Manager fails to manage expectations around onboarding, the training process, time required to fix an issue, or even the expected outcomes of regular meetings or touchpoints, the satisfaction levels for customers would start slipping. Allow this to happen a few times and the customer will eventually become a non-believer in your ability to manage the relationship.

#8 Trying to Handle Too Many Accounts

Customer Success Managers usually don’t cause this problem and typically inherit it, based on the decision of a leader who thinks you can successfully manage ‘X’ accounts. However, if you figure out that you have too many accounts to do justice (considering the maturity of the product, clients, organization & tools available) it is crucial to have this conversation (armed with data points) with your manager to limit your responsibility to what you can reasonably succeed with.

Read through these customer success manager mistakes and let us know in the comments below if we have missed any in this list.

Get the #1 Customer Success Platform

For Growing CS Teams

Get a Demo

Originally Published May 13th, 2020, Updated June 22nd, 2020

Anshi Bhadoria

Anshi has over 12 years of experience in demand generation, digital marketing, and managing global teams. In her prior role as head of marketing operations for a high growth US healthcare tech organization she transformed marketing from cost to revenue center.

Related Articles


1 year ago

Can a SaaS customer who has requested to cancel be saved? - SmartKarrot l Comprehensive Customer Success

[…] if not these two reasons then it could be due to the CSM failing to give in-person attention to the customer through initial stages. In any case, it is the prime […]

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Ready to see us in action?

Schedule a demo now!